ScorebookIQ
D-I2026–27Elo

Wrestling

Division

Season

Rank wrestlers by

The ranking system changes every list and projection on the site. How they work

Mathew Gummere, career

Mathew Gummere 2025–26

Case Western Reserve, 184 pounds, Division III. 20–11 in 2025–26; 36–20 over 3 seasons. On the 2026–27 roster at Case Western Reserve: see the team.

2025–26 at Case Western Reserve

RecordFallsTech fallsMajorsBonusEloGlicko-2RPI
20–1151660%16321700±170.565

Résumé

What selection committees weigh. Updates with every result.
Win %
.645
20–11 in counted bouts
Vs top 10
0–2
By Elo rank at 184
Vs top 33
3–7
3 quality wins
Bad losses
1
Schedule
79thof 184
Toughest at 184. Opponents average 1551 Elo
RPI
58thof 193
.565 at 184

Match log

Result
Nov 1W
Randolph
Fall 4:45 Mount Union Invitational
Cons. Round 5
Nov 15W
Adrian
MD 8-0 Adrian vs Case Western Reserve
Nov 22L
Baldwin Wallace
Dec 11-5 BW Invitational
Nov 22W
Manchester
MD 12-0 Baldwin Wallace Invitational
Quarterfinal
Nov 22W
Manchester
Dec 5-1 Baldwin Wallace Invitational
Semifinal
Dec 20W
Arcadia
Fall 1:02 Arcadia vs Case Western Reserve
Dec 20W
Messiah
Dec 5-2 Case Western Reserve vs Messiah
Dec 20W
Ithaca
INJ 4:45 Case Western Reserve vs Ithaca
Jan 3W
Centenary
MD 14-2 Case Western Reserve vs Centenary
Jan 3W
Gettysburg
MD 12-0 Case Western Reserve vs Gettysburg
Jan 3L
Johns Hopkins
Dec 5-4 Case Western Reserve vs Johns Hopkins
Jan 10W
Manchester
MD 13-4 Case Western Reserve vs Manchester
Jan 10L
Mount Union
Fall 6:48 Case Western Reserve vs Mount Union
Jan 17W
Manchester
Fall 2:48 Tom Jarman Spartan Mat Classic
Jan 17L
Wabash
Fall 3:52 Tom Jarman Spartan Mat Classic
3rd place
Jan 17L
Wabash
Dec 4-2 Tom Jarman Spartan Mat Classic
SF
Jan 23W
Washington & Jefferson
Fall 4:54 Case Western Reserve vs Washington & Jefferson
Jan 30L
Wisconsin-Whitewater
Dec 8-2 Pete Willson Invitational
Jan 30L
Roanoke
MD 15-5 Pete Willson Invitational
Jan 30W
Ozarks
MD 8-0 Pete Willson Invitational
Jan 30W
Wheaton (IL)
Dec 5-4 Pete Willson Invitational
Feb 7W
Baldwin Wallace
Dec 4-1 John Summa Invitational
Feb 7L
Alfred State
Fall 2:04 39th John Summa Invitational
Final
Feb 27W
Alma
TF 15-0 NCAA Division III Region V Championships
Cons R2
Feb 27L
North Central
Dec 13-6 NCAA Division III Region V Championships
QF
Feb 27W
Albion
Dec 5-4 NCAA Division III Region V Championships
R1
Feb 28W
Wabash
Fall 6:34 NCAA Division III Region V Championships
3rd place
Feb 28W
Manchester
Dec 8-7 NCAA Division III Region V Championships
Cons R3
Feb 28W
Wisconsin-Whitewater
Dec 2-1 TB1 NCAA Division III Region V Championships
Cons SF
Mar 13L
North Central
TF 22-4 2026 NCAA Division III Championships
Cons R1
Mar 13L
Averett
TF 17-1 2026 NCAA Division III Championships
Pigtail

Best wins

  1. 21Xavier Pommells
    Ithaca, INJ 4:45, Dec 20
    1701
  2. 22Zachary Huckaby
    Wabash, Fall 6:34, Feb 28
    1700
  3. 31Owen Turnbow
    Albion, Dec 5-4, Feb 27
    1669
  4. 71Nate Kovalcik
    Messiah, Dec 5-2, Dec 20
    1554
  5. 77RJ Samuels
    Wisconsin-Whitewater, Dec 2-1 TB1, Feb 28
    1539

Ordered by the opponent’s Elo at the end of 2025–26; the number on the left is their rank.

How the wins came

Fall 5Tech fall 1Major 6Decision 7

Losses by decision (5), fall (3), major (1), tech fall (2).

Elo through the season

30 rated bouts
16831500

Earlier: 2024–25Full careerLater: 2026–27

The week in college wrestling

Every Monday: the biggest upsets, who moved in the rankings, and what stood out across D-I, D-II, D-III and women's. Free.