Mathew Gummere

Case Western Reserve, 184 pounds, Division III. 2 seasons on ScorebookIQ, 29–18 in all. On the 2026–27 roster at Case Western Reserve: see the team.

Career record	Seasons	Bonus	Best NCAA finish
29–18	2	62%	–

Career

Season	Team	Record	NCAA
	Case Western Reserve 184 lbs, Division III	20–11	–
	Case Western Reserve 184 lbs, Division III	9–7	–

Seasons are linked by name, school and weight. Ratings start fresh each season.

2025–26 at Case Western Reserve

Case Western Reserve, 184 pounds, Division III, 20–11, ranked 43rd at 184 by Elo rating.

Record	Falls	Tech falls	Majors	Bonus	Vs top 20	Elo	Glicko-2	RPI
20–11	5	1	6	60%	0–5	1631	1698±170	.535

Last 10 WLWLWWWWLL Compare with another wrestler

Match log

			Result
Nov 1	W	Tyler Balint Randolph	Fall 4:45	Mount Union Invitational Cons. Round 5
Nov 15	W	Benjamin Grenesko Adrian	MD 8-0	Adrian vs Case Western Reserve
Nov 22	L	Remington Bauer Baldwin Wallace	Dec 11-5	BW Invitational
Nov 22	W	Cory Dowden Manchester	MD 12-0	Baldwin Wallace Invitational Quarterfinal
Nov 22	W	Ethan Risner Manchester	Dec 5-1	Baldwin Wallace Invitational Semifinal
Dec 20	W	Jagger Gray Arcadia	Fall 1:02	Arcadia vs Case Western Reserve
Dec 20	W	Nate Kovalcik Messiah	Dec 5-2	Case Western Reserve vs Messiah
Dec 20	W	Xavier Pommells Ithaca	INJ 4:45	Case Western Reserve vs Ithaca
Jan 3	W	Alex Mercado Centenary	MD 14-2	Case Western Reserve vs Centenary
Jan 3	W	Joe Dietz Gettysburg	MD 12-0	Case Western Reserve vs Gettysburg
Jan 3	L	Kadin Khalloufi Johns Hopkins	Dec 5-4	Case Western Reserve vs Johns Hopkins
Jan 10	W	Ethan Risner Manchester	MD 13-4	Case Western Reserve vs Manchester
Jan 10	L	Blaine Chrisman Mount Union	Fall 6:48	Case Western Reserve vs Mount Union
Jan 17	W	Luke Dwyer Manchester	Fall 2:48	Tom Jarman Spartan Mat Classic
Jan 17	L	Michael Taheny Wabash	Fall 3:52	Tom Jarman Spartan Mat Classic 3rd place
Jan 17	L	Zachary Huckaby Wabash	Dec 4-2	Tom Jarman Spartan Mat Classic SF
Jan 23	W	Zander Tompkins Washington & Jefferson	Fall 4:54	Case Western Reserve vs Washington & Jefferson
Jan 30	L	RJ Samuels Wisconsin-Whitewater	Dec 8-2	Pete Willson Invitational
Jan 30	L	Hunter Moore Roanoke	MD 15-5	Pete Willson Invitational
Jan 30	W	Nawab Singh Ozarks	MD 8-0	Pete Willson Invitational
Jan 30	W	Jacob Kraker Wheaton (IL)	Dec 5-4	Pete Willson Invitational
Feb 7	W	Dominic Pagan Baldwin Wallace	Dec 4-1	John Summa Invitational
Feb 7	L	Sean Malenfant Alfred State	Fall 2:04	39th John Summa Invitational Final
Feb 27	W	Waylon Lamkin Alma	TF 15-0	NCAA Division III Region V Championships Cons R2
Feb 27	L	Casey Aikman North Central	Dec 13-6	NCAA Division III Region V Championships QF
Feb 27	W	Owen Turnbow Albion	Dec 5-4	NCAA Division III Region V Championships R1
Feb 28	W	Zachary Huckaby Wabash	Fall 6:34	NCAA Division III Region V Championships 3rd place
Feb 28	W	Ethan Risner Manchester	Dec 8-7	NCAA Division III Region V Championships Cons R3
Feb 28	W	RJ Samuels Wisconsin-Whitewater	Dec 2-1 TB1	NCAA Division III Region V Championships Cons SF
Mar 13	L	Casey Aikman North Central	TF 22-4	2026 NCAA Division III Championships Cons R1
Mar 13	L	Khalil Mitchell Averett	TF 17-1	2026 NCAA Division III Championships Pigtail

Best wins

21Xavier Pommells
Ithaca, INJ 4:45, Dec 20
1702
22Zachary Huckaby
Wabash, Fall 6:34, Feb 28
1700
31Owen Turnbow
Albion, Dec 5-4, Feb 27
1669
71Nate Kovalcik
Messiah, Dec 5-2, Dec 20
1555
82Jacob Kraker
Wheaton (IL), Dec 5-4, Jan 30
1531

Ordered by the opponent’s Elo at the end of 2025–26; the number on the left is their rank.

How the wins came

Fall 5Tech fall 1Major 6Decision 7

Losses by decision (5), fall (3), major (1), tech fall (2).

Elo through the season

30 rated bouts

2024–25 at Case Western Reserve

Case Western Reserve, 184 pounds, Division III, 9–7, ranked 88th at 184 by Elo rating.

Record	Falls	Tech falls	Majors	Bonus	Vs top 20	Elo	Glicko-2	RPI
9–7	1	2	3	67%	0–1	1526	1534±230	.485

Last 10 WLWWWLWLLL Compare with another wrestler

Match log

			Result
Nov 2	W	Noah Harris Averett	MD 18-5	Adrian College Invitational R3
Nov 10	W	Ronald Dietz RIT	Dec	Bob Del Rosa Ohio Intercollegiate Open
Nov 10	W	Van Skinner Indianapolis	Dec	Bob Del Rosa Ohio Intercollegiate Open
Nov 23	L	Remington Bauer Baldwin Wallace	Dec 4-1	BW Invitational
Dec 7	L	Zach Borzio Williams	Dec 4-0	RIT Invitational
Dec 7	W	Ty Saeturn Norwich	TF 16-0	RIT Invitational QF
Dec 7	W	Charlie Rossner St. John Fisher	TF 15-0	RIT Invitational R1
Jan 4	L	Carter Sorenson Augsburg	Dec 11-5	Augsburg vs Case Western Reserve
Jan 4	W	Tate Crowell Millikin	Dec 4-0	Case Western Reserve vs Millikin
Jan 4	W	Randy Manos Aurora	Fall 2:34	Aurora vs Case Western Reserve
Jan 11	W	Muhammad Jallaq Otterbein	MD 16-5	Case Western Reserve vs Otterbein
Jan 31	L	Gavin Kohel Wisconsin-Whitewater	TF 20-3	Pete Willson Invitational R1
Feb 8	W	Des Perry Ohio Wesleyan	MD 12-0	John Summa Invitational
Feb 8	L	Caiden Hooks Otterbein	Fall 0:21	John Summa Invitational Cons. Semi
Feb 28	L	Benicio Martinez Millikin	Dec 7-4	NCAA Division III Region 5 Championships Consolation Round 2
Feb 28	L	Payton Geigner North Central	Dec 5-0	NCAA Division III Lower Midwest Regional Championships R1

Best wins

93Tate Crowell
Millikin, Dec 4-0, Jan 4
1517
99Noah Harris
Averett, MD 18-5, Nov 2
1506
111Des Perry
Ohio Wesleyan, MD 12-0, Feb 8
1478
115Ronald Dietz
RIT, Dec, Nov 10
1454
137Charlie Rossner
St. John Fisher, TF 15-0, Dec 7
1420

Ordered by the opponent’s Elo at the end of 2024–25; the number on the left is their rank.

How the wins came

Fall 1Tech fall 2Major 3Decision 3

Losses by decision (5), tech fall (1), fall (1).

Elo through the season

16 rated bouts