ScorebookIQ
D-I2026–27Elo

Wrestling

Division

Season

Rank wrestlers by

The ranking system changes every list and projection on the site. How they work

Matthew Caldwell, career

Matthew Caldwell 2025–26

Penn State Behrend, 285 pounds, Division III. 8–9 in 2025–26; 23–21 over 3 seasons.

2025–26 at Penn State Behrend

RecordFallsTech fallsMajorsBonusEloGlicko-2RPI
8–931163%14651416±232.501

Résumé

What selection committees weigh. Updates with every result.
Win %
.471
8–9 in counted bouts
Vs top 10
–
By Elo rank at 285
Vs top 33
–
No bouts against the top 33 yet
Bad losses
2
Schedule
111thof 188
Toughest at 285. Opponents average 1531 Elo
RPI
89thof 193
.501 at 285

Match log

Result
Nov 8L
Waynesburg
Dec 7-3 W&J Invitational
QF
Nov 15W
Lycoming
TF 20-5 Lycoming vs Penn State Behrend
Nov 18W
Pitt-Bradford
Fall 0:17 Penn State Behrend vs Pitt-Bradford
Nov 22L
Baldwin Wallace
Dec 4-3 BW Invitational
Nov 22L
Muskingum
Dec 6-3 Baldwin Wallace Invitational
Dec 6L
Norwich
MFF RIT Invitational
Cons R5
Dec 13W
Forfeit
FF Penn State Altoona vs Penn State Behrend
Dec 13W
Joey Baronick
Mercyhurst
Fall 4:59 Mercyhurst vs Penn State Behrend
Jan 10W
Alfred State
MD 11-3 Alfred State vs Penn State Behrend
Jan 10L
Penn College
Fall 3:38 Penn College vs Penn State Behrend
Jan 17W
St. John Fisher
INJ 5:19 Penn State Behrend vs St. John Fisher
Jan 23W
Waynesburg
Dec 6-2 Penn State Behrend vs Waynesburg
Jan 30L
Joey Baronick
Mercyhurst
MD 13-1 Mercyhurst vs Penn State Behrend
Feb 14L
Alfred State
Fall 1:43 AMCC Championships
Feb 14W
Alfred State
Fall AMCC Championships
3rd place
Feb 27L
Stevens
Dec 5-0 2026 NCAA Division III Region II Championships
7th place
Feb 27L
Lycoming
Fall 3:52 NCAA Region II Championships
Cons. Round 5

Best wins

  1. 55Jackson Burns
    St. John Fisher, INJ 5:19, Jan 17
    1605
  2. 71Aaron Johnson
    Alfred State, MD 11-3, Jan 10
    1567
  3. 70Austin Fleming
    Waynesburg, Dec 6-2, Jan 23
    1567
  4. 174Colton Hai
    Alfred State, Fall, Feb 14
    1346

Ordered by the opponent’s Elo at the end of 2025–26; the number on the left is their rank.

How the wins came

Fall 3Tech fall 1Major 1Decision 1

Losses by decision (4), mff (1), fall (3), major (1).

Elo through the season

14 rated bouts
15781465

Earlier: 2024–25Full careerLater: 2026–27

The week in college wrestling

Every Monday: the biggest upsets, who moved in the rankings, and what stood out across D-I, D-II, D-III and women's. Free.