ScorebookIQ
D-I2026–27Elo

Wrestling

Division

Season

Rank wrestlers by

The ranking system changes every list and projection on the site. How they work

Jay McDonnell, career

Jay McDonnell 2025–26

Ithaca, 133 pounds, Division III. 26–6 in 2025–26; 35–10 over 3 seasons. On the 2026–27 roster at Ithaca: see the team.

2025–26 at Ithaca

RecordFallsTech fallsMajorsBonusEloGlicko-2RPI
26–683458%17681939±198.634

Résumé

What selection committees weigh. Updates with every result.
Win %
.813
26–6 in counted bouts
Vs top 10
0–3
By Elo rank at 133
Vs top 33
2–6
2 quality wins
Bad losses
0
No losses to wrestlers under .500
Schedule
49thof 187
Toughest at 133. Opponents average 1589 Elo
RPI
12thof 194
.634 at 133

Match log

Result
Nov 7W
Oswego
Fall 2:17 Ithaca Invitational
Nov 7W
Springfield
Fall 3:29 Ithaca Invitational
Nov 8W
Teammate, so it doesn’t count toward the record
MFF Ithaca Invitational
1st place
Nov 8W
Castleton
Dec 5-0 Ithaca Invitational
SF
Nov 15W
Colin Higgins
Millersville
Dec 9-4 Shorty Hitchcock Classic
Nov 15W
Sean Garreston
Navy
Fall 1:55 Shorty Hitchcock Classic
3rd place
Nov 15W
Logan Alexander
West Virginia
MD 11-3 unattached Shorty Hitchcock Classic
QF
Nov 22W
Merchant Marine
Fall 6:11 NYS Collegiate Championships
Nov 22W
NYU
Dec 2-1 NYS Collegiate Championships
Nov 22W
Isaak Arevalo
USMAPS
MD 13-5 NYS Collegiate Championships
1st place
Dec 5W
Johnson & Wales
Fall 4:15 New Standard Invitational
Dec 5W
Misericordia
TF 22-3 New Standard Invitational
Dec 5W
Washington and Lee
Dec 7-5 New Standard Invitational
Dec 5L
Johnson & Wales
FF New Standard Invitational
3rd place
Dec 6W
Washington and Lee
MD 12-3 New Standard Invitational
3rd place
Dec 6L
TCNJ
Dec 4-1 New Standard Invitational
SF
Jan 4W
Castleton
Dec 4-2 Castleton vs Ithaca
Jan 9L
Wisconsin-Eau Claire
Dec 11-10 Ithaca vs Wisconsin-Eau Claire
Jan 9W
Wilkes
TF 20-4 Ithaca vs Wilkes
Jan 9W
TCNJ
TF 19-4 Ithaca vs TCNJ
Jan 10W
Messiah
Dec 8-1 Ithaca vs Messiah
Jan 30L
TCNJ
TF 17-2 Ithaca vs TCNJ
Jan 31W
Stevens
Dec 8-2 Ithaca vs Stevens
Feb 7W
Williams
MD 13-2 Ithaca vs Williams
Feb 7W
Wesleyan
Fall 1:26 Ithaca vs Wesleyan
Feb 11W
Cortland
Dec 7-3 Cortland vs Ithaca
Feb 13W
Wilkes
Fall 7:00 Ithaca vs Wilkes
Feb 18W
St. John Fisher
Dec 4-1 Ithaca vs St. John Fisher
Feb 27W
Centenary
Dec 4-1 NCAA Division III Region 2 Championships
1st place
Feb 27W
Pitt-Bradford
Fall 2:09 NCAA Region II Championships
Champ. Round 2
Feb 27W
Cortland
Dec 9-6 NCAA Region II Championships
Quarterfinal
Mar 13L
Wisconsin-Eau Claire
Dec 8-5 2026 NCAA Division III Championships
Cons R2
Mar 13L
Wartburg
Dec 4-1 2026 NCAA Division III Championships
R16

Best wins

  1. 23Rocco Futia
    Cortland, Dec 7-3, Feb 11
    1681
  2. 38Harrison Gordon
    NYU, Dec 2-1, Nov 22
    1633
  3. 48Daniel Haws
    Centenary, Dec 4-1, Feb 27
    1611
  4. 49Vincent Ziccardi
    Washington and Lee, Dec 7-5, Dec 5
    1607
  5. 53Aidan Shufelt
    Castleton, Dec 5-0, Nov 8
    1603

Ordered by the opponent’s Elo at the end of 2025–26; the number on the left is their rank.

How the wins came

Fall 8Tech fall 3Major 4Decision 11

Losses by ff (1), decision (4), tech fall (1).

Elo through the season

31 rated bouts
18061500

Earlier: 2024–25Full careerLater: 2026–27

The week in college wrestling

Every Monday: the biggest upsets, who moved in the rankings, and what stood out across D-I, D-II, D-III and women's. Free.