Jay McDonnell

Ithaca, 133 pounds, Division III. 2 seasons on ScorebookIQ, 30–9 in all.

Career record	Seasons	Bonus	Best NCAA finish
30–9	2	57%	–

Career

Moved from Binghamton to Ithaca (Division III) for 2025–26.

Season	Team	Record	NCAA
	Ithaca 133 lbs, Division III	26–6	–
	Binghamton 125 lbs	4–3	–

Seasons are linked by name, school and weight. Ratings start fresh each season.

2025–26 at Ithaca

Ithaca, 133 pounds, Division III, 26–6, ranked 10th at 133 by Elo rating.

Record	Falls	Tech falls	Majors	Bonus	Vs top 20	Elo	Glicko-2	RPI
26–6	8	3	4	58%	0–5	1769	1941±196	.595

Last 10 WWWWWWWWLL Compare with another wrestler

Match log

			Result
Nov 7	W	Frank Downing Oswego	Fall 2:17	Ithaca Invitational
Nov 7	W	Jaden Colwell Springfield	Fall 3:29	Ithaca Invitational
Nov 8	W	George McAteer Teammate, so it doesn’t count toward the record	MFF	Ithaca Invitational 1st place
Nov 8	W	Aidan Shufelt Castleton	Dec 5-0	Ithaca Invitational SF
Nov 15	W	Colin Higgins Millersville	Dec 9-4	Shorty Hitchcock Classic
Nov 15	W	Sean Garreston Navy	Fall 1:55	Shorty Hitchcock Classic 3rd place
Nov 15	W	Logan Alexander West Virginia	MD 11-3 unattached	Shorty Hitchcock Classic QF
Nov 22	W	Charles Case Merchant Marine	Fall 6:11	NYS Collegiate Championships
Nov 22	W	Harrison Gordon NYU	Dec 2-1	NYS Collegiate Championships
Nov 22	W	Isaak Arevalo USMAPS	MD 13-5	NYS Collegiate Championships 1st place
Dec 5	W	Jahir Aguilar Johnson & Wales	Fall 4:15	New Standard Invitational
Dec 5	W	Hayden Best Misericordia	TF 22-3	New Standard Invitational
Dec 5	W	Vincent Ziccardi Washington and Lee	Dec 7-5	New Standard Invitational
Dec 5	L	Peyton Ellis Johnson & Wales	FF	New Standard Invitational 3rd place
Dec 6	W	Calvin Wiedemer Washington and Lee	MD 12-3	New Standard Invitational 3rd place
Dec 6	L	Garrett Totten TCNJ	Dec 4-1	New Standard Invitational SF
Jan 4	W	Stone Farnsworth Castleton	Dec 4-2	Castleton vs Ithaca
Jan 9	L	Wyatt Unser Wisconsin-Eau Claire	Dec 11-10	Ithaca vs Wisconsin-Eau Claire
Jan 9	W	Sam Kimmel Wilkes	TF 20-4	Ithaca vs Wilkes
Jan 9	W	Luke Reitter TCNJ	TF 19-4	Ithaca vs TCNJ
Jan 10	W	Tyler Ratledge Messiah	Dec 8-1	Ithaca vs Messiah
Jan 30	L	Garrett Totten TCNJ	TF 17-2	Ithaca vs TCNJ
Jan 31	W	Vincent Principe Stevens	Dec 8-2	Ithaca vs Stevens
Feb 7	W	Jake Strianese Williams	MD 13-2	Ithaca vs Williams
Feb 7	W	Taylor Tan Wesleyan	Fall 1:26	Ithaca vs Wesleyan
Feb 11	W	Rocco Futia Cortland	Dec 7-3	Cortland vs Ithaca
Feb 13	W	Connor Kerwin Wilkes	Fall 7:00	Ithaca vs Wilkes
Feb 18	W	Derek Bernardino St. John Fisher	Dec 4-1	Ithaca vs St. John Fisher
Feb 27	W	Daniel Haws Centenary	Dec 4-1	NCAA Division III Region 2 Championships 1st place
Feb 27	W	Mike Worsen Pitt-Bradford	Fall 2:09	NCAA Region II Championships Champ. Round 2
Feb 27	W	Rocco Futia Cortland	Dec 9-6	NCAA Region II Championships Quarterfinal
Mar 13	L	Wyatt Unser Wisconsin-Eau Claire	Dec 8-5	2026 NCAA Division III Championships Cons R2
Mar 13	L	Patrick Mullen Wartburg	Dec 4-1	2026 NCAA Division III Championships R16

Best wins

22Rocco Futia
Cortland, Dec 7-3, Feb 11
1682
38Harrison Gordon
NYU, Dec 2-1, Nov 22
1633
48Daniel Haws
Centenary, Dec 4-1, Feb 27
1612
49Vincent Ziccardi
Washington and Lee, Dec 7-5, Dec 5
1607
53Aidan Shufelt
Castleton, Dec 5-0, Nov 8
1603

Ordered by the opponent’s Elo at the end of 2025–26; the number on the left is their rank.

How the wins came

Fall 8Tech fall 3Major 4Decision 11

Losses by ff (1), decision (4), tech fall (1).

Elo through the season

31 rated bouts

2024–25 at Binghamton

Binghamton, 125 pounds, Division I, 4–3, ranked 69th at 125 by Elo rating.

Record	Falls	Tech falls	Majors	Bonus	Vs top 20	Elo	Glicko-2	RPI
4–3	2	0	0	50%	–	1540	1519±326	.420

Last 10 LLWWWWL Compare with another wrestler

Match log

			Result
Nov 10	L	Max Elton Buffalo	Dec 3-2	Journeymen Collegiate Classic 3rd place
Nov 10	L	James Garcia Franklin & Marshall	Fall 1:47	Journeymen Collegiate Classic RR Round 1
Nov 10	W	Teague Strobel Hofstra	Fall 5:29	Journeymen Collegiate Classic RR Round 3
Nov 24	W	Aidan Shufelt Buffalo	Dec 4-1	Big Red Invitational Rd 1
Nov 24	W	Joe Sciarrone Cornell	Dec 6-3	Big Red Invitational Rd 2
Nov 24	W	Michael Baker Sacred Heart	Fall 1:18	Big Red Invitational Rd 3
Jan 10	L	Jay Peace American	MD 14-4	David H. Lehman '68 F&M Open Cons R16

Best wins

103Joe Sciarrone
Cornell, Dec 6-3, Nov 24
1489
135Teague Strobel
Hofstra, Fall 5:29, Nov 10
1398

Ordered by the opponent’s Elo at the end of 2024–25; the number on the left is their rank.

How the wins came

Fall 2Tech fall 0Major 0Decision 2

Losses by decision (1), fall (1), major (1).

Elo through the season

7 rated bouts