Joey Buttler

Indiana, 149 pounds, Division I. 2 seasons on ScorebookIQ, 21–25 in all. On the 2026–27 roster at Indiana: see the team.

Career record	Seasons	Bonus	Best NCAA finish
21–25	2	33%	–

Career

Season	Team	Record	NCAA
	Indiana 149 lbs	9–14	–
	Indiana 141 lbs	12–11	–

Seasons are linked by name, school and weight. Ratings start fresh each season.

2025–26 at Indiana

Indiana, 149 pounds, Division I, 9–14, ranked 111th at 149 by Elo rating.

Record	Falls	Tech falls	Majors	Bonus	Vs top 20	Elo	Glicko-2	RPI
9–14	2	0	2	44%	0–4	1483	1511±194	.496

Last 10 LLLLWLWLLL Compare with another wrestler

Match log

			Result
Nov 8	L	Lucas Kapusta Lock Haven	Dec 4-2	Indiana vs Lock Haven
Nov 9	L	Anthony Evanitsky Lehigh	Fall 1:13	Journeymen Collegiate Classic
Nov 9	W	Aidan O'Shea Franklin & Marshall	Fall 4:19	Journeymen Collegiate Classic Round 3
Nov 14	W	Richard Fedalen Columbia	MD 14-6	Columbia vs Indiana
Nov 23	L	Hunter Hollingsworth Oklahoma	Dec 4-2	Indiana vs Oklahoma
Dec 5	W	Jimmy Nugent Central Michigan	Dec 6-1	Central Michigan vs Indiana
Dec 7	W	Kyle Lew Little Rock	Dec 9-4	Indiana vs Little Rock
Dec 13	W	Mason Barvitskie Army	MD 11-1	Army vs Indiana
Dec 29	W	Charlie Fifield Illinois	Fall 1:47	Midlands Championships Champ. R1
Dec 29	L	Andre Gonzales Cal Poly	Dec 11-5	Ken Kraft Midlands Championships Cons. R4
Dec 29	L	Sergio Lemley Michigan	Dec 5-1	Ken Kraft Midlands Championships Quarterfinal
Dec 29	W	Colin Kacena Central Michigan	Dec 5-4	Ken Kraft Midlands Championships R16
Jan 11	L	Ethan Stiles Ohio State	Fall 2:55	Indiana vs Ohio State
Jan 18	L	Carter Young Maryland	Dec 8-1	Indiana vs Maryland
Jan 23	L	Shayne VanNess Penn State	TF 20-3	Indiana vs Penn State
Jan 26	L	Evan Gosz Michigan State	MD 20-6	Indiana vs Michigan State
Jan 30	L	Michael Gioffre Illinois	Dec 4-3	Illinois vs Indiana
Feb 7	W	Joseph Zargo Wisconsin	Dec 4-1 SV1	Indiana vs Wisconsin
Feb 15	L	Chance Lamer Nebraska	Dec 5-3	Indiana vs Nebraska
Feb 20	W	Gavin Brown Purdue	Dec 5-4	Indiana vs Purdue
Mar 7	L	August Hibler Northwestern	Dec 9-8	2026 Big Ten Championships Cons R1
Mar 7	L	Gavin Brown Purdue	Dec 2-1	2026 Big Ten Championships PUR log bout 1
Mar 7	L	Chance Lamer Nebraska	MD 9-1	2026 Big Ten Championships R1

Best wins

28Joseph Zargo
Wisconsin, Dec 4-1 SV1, Feb 7
1652
67Jimmy Nugent
Central Michigan, Dec 6-1, Dec 5
1562
88Gavin Brown
Purdue, Dec 5-4, Feb 20
1521
91Aidan O'Shea
Franklin & Marshall, Fall 4:19, Nov 9
1517
100Mason Barvitskie
Army, MD 11-1, Dec 13
1497

Ordered by the opponent’s Elo at the end of 2025–26; the number on the left is their rank.

How the wins came

Fall 2Tech fall 0Major 2Decision 5

Losses by decision (9), fall (2), tech fall (1), major (2).

Elo through the season

23 rated bouts

2024–25 at Indiana

Indiana, 141 pounds, Division I, 12–11, ranked 72nd at 141 by Elo rating.

Record	Falls	Tech falls	Majors	Bonus	Vs top 20	Elo	Glicko-2	RPI
12–11	1	1	1	25%	1–5	1528	1633±190	.499

Last 10 LLLLWWWLLL Compare with another wrestler

Match log

			Result
Nov 9	W	Kellan Aure Central Michigan	Dec 4-2	Michigan State Open 3rd place
Nov 9	W	Kellan Aure Central Michigan	Dec 4-2	Michigan State Open 3rd place
Nov 9	W	Carsen Richards Lake Erie	Dec 11-8	Michigan State Open Cons SF
Nov 9	W	Carsen Richards Lake Erie	Dec 6-4	Michigan State Open R16
Nov 9	L	Gabriel Bouyssou Spartan Combat RTC	Dec 8-5 Bouyssou unattached	Michigan State Open SF
Nov 23	L	Josh Koderhandt Navy	Fall 2:11	Navy Classic QF
Nov 23	W	Trevor Nugent Bucknell	TF 17-1	Navy Classic R16
Dec 20	W	Carter Bailey Lehigh	Dec 13-10	Sheridan Tournament Cons SF
Dec 20	W	Pat Phillips Franklin & Marshall	MD 10-2 unattached	Sheridan Open Consolation Quarterfinals
Dec 20	W	Bryce Kresho Franklin & Marshall	Dec 7-2	Sheridan Open Third Place
Dec 29	L	Dante Frinzi Harvard	MD 17-7	Midlands Championships Cons R2
Dec 29	W	Giosue Hickman Northwestern	Dec 5-3	Midlands Championships Cons. Round 1
Dec 29	L	Evan Mougalian Penn	TF 15-0	Midlands Championships R1
Jan 26	L	Cameron Catrabone Michigan	Dec 8-1	Indiana vs Michigan
Feb 1	L	Sam Cartella Northwestern	Dec 9-2	Indiana vs Northwestern
Feb 9	L	Dylan D'Emilio Ohio State	Dec 5-3	Indiana vs Ohio State
Feb 16	L	Ridge Lovett Nebraska	Fall 1:52	Indiana vs Nebraska
Feb 21	W	Yuta Otero Chattanooga	Fall 2:54	Chattanooga vs Indiana
Mar 8	W	Sam Cartella Northwestern	Dec 4-3	Big Ten Championships 9th-Place Semifinal
Mar 8	W	Clayton Jones Michigan State	Dec 18-12	2025 Big Ten Championships Cons R1
Mar 8	L	Andrew Clark Rutgers	Dec 8-1	2025 Big Ten Championships Cons R2
Mar 8	L	Dylan D'Emilio Ohio State	TF 18-0	2025 Big Ten Championships R1
Mar 9	L	Drew Roberts Minnesota	Dec 5-2	Big Ten Championships 9th place

Best wins

13Bryce Kresho
Franklin & Marshall, Dec 7-2, Dec 20
1710
41Sam Cartella
Northwestern, Dec 4-3, Mar 8
1587
68Carter Bailey
Lehigh, Dec 13-10, Dec 20
1534
86Pat Phillips
Franklin & Marshall, MD 10-2 unattached, Dec 20
1506
95Giosue Hickman
Northwestern, Dec 5-3, Dec 29
1487

Ordered by the opponent’s Elo at the end of 2024–25; the number on the left is their rank.

How the wins came

Fall 1Tech fall 1Major 1Decision 9

Losses by decision (6), fall (2), major (1), tech fall (2).

Elo through the season

23 rated bouts