ScorebookIQ
D-I2025–26Elo

Division

Season

Rank wrestlers by

The ranking system changes every list and projection on the site. How they work

Toby Schoffstall

VMI, 197 pounds, Division I. 2 seasons on ScorebookIQ, 21–19 in all. On the 2026–27 roster at VMI: see the team.

Career recordSeasonsBonusBest NCAA finish
21–19262%–

Career

SeasonTeamRecordNCAA
VMI
197 lbs
10–13–
VMI
197 lbs
11–6–

Seasons are linked by name, school and weight. Ratings start fresh each season.

2025–26 at VMI

VMI, 197 pounds, Division I, 10–13, ranked 92nd at 197 by Elo rating.

RecordFallsTech fallsMajorsBonusVs top 20EloGlicko-2RPI
10–1312140%–14731450±196.455

Match log

Result
Nov 2L
Minnesota
Fall 2:19 Southeast Open
Nov 2L
Campbell
Fall 1:34 Southeast Open
Open Cons Round of 16
Nov 7W
Forfeit
FF Emory & Henry vs VMI
Nov 9L
Michigan
MD 9-1 Michigan vs VMI
Nov 22W
Duke
MD 11-1 Duke vs VMI
Dec 5L
Cornell
MD 15-4 Cliff Keen Las Vegas Invitational
Cons R16
Dec 5L
Navy
MD 16-5 Cliff Keen Las Vegas Invitational
R32
Dec 20L
Bloomsburg
Dec 6-3 Bloomsburg vs VMI
Dec 20W
Sacred Heart
Dec 8-5 Sacred Heart vs VMI
Jan 3L
Missouri
Fall 0:28 Soldier Salute
Jan 3L
North Carolina
TF 17-2 Soldier Salute
Jan 3W
Minnesota
Dec 6-1 Soldier Salute
Jan 3W
Oklahoma
Dec 7-6 Soldier Salute
Jan 3L
Wyoming
DEF 1:37 Soldier Salute
7th place
Jan 15L
Appalachian State
MD 9-0 Appalachian State vs VMI
Jan 23W
Bellarmine
Fall 2:14 Bellarmine vs VMI
Feb 6L
Chattanooga
TF 17-2 Chattanooga vs VMI
Feb 22W
The Citadel
Dec 4-2 The Citadel vs VMI
Feb 23W
Presbyterian
TF 15-0 Presbyterian vs VMI
Mar 6W
Davidson
TF 17-0 2026 SoCon Championships
Cons QF
Mar 6L
Bellarmine
Dec 10-3 2026 SoCon Championships
R1
Mar 7L
Bellarmine
Dec 5-4 2026 SoCon Championships
3rd place
Mar 7W
The Citadel
Dec 14-8 2026 SoCon Championships
Cons SF

Best wins

  1. 53Anthony Harris
    Oklahoma, Dec 7-6, Jan 3
    1567
  2. 84Silas Dailey
    Minnesota, Dec 6-1, Jan 3
    1497
  3. 87Andrew Liber
    Bellarmine, Fall 2:14, Jan 23
    1489
  4. 95Adam Ortega
    The Citadel, Dec 4-2, Feb 22
    1469
  5. 123Dylan Smith
    Davidson, TF 17-0, Mar 6
    1388

Ordered by the opponent’s Elo at the end of 2025–26; the number on the left is their rank.

How the wins came

Fall 1Tech fall 2Major 1Decision 5

Losses by fall (3), major (4), decision (3), tech fall (2), def (1).

Elo through the season

21 rated bouts
15001372

2024–25 at VMI

VMI, 197 pounds, Division I, 11–6, ranked 47th at 197 by Elo rating.

RecordFallsTech fallsMajorsBonusVs top 20EloGlicko-2RPI
11–625282%0–215741587±246.458

Match log

Result
Nov 9W
Franklin & Marshall
MD 9-0 Franklin & Marshall vs VMI
Nov 9W
Sacred Heart
Fall 0:57 Sacred Heart vs VMI
Nov 17W
Forfeit
FF Morgan State vs VMI
Nov 17W
Joseph Redden
Marymount
TF 16-0 Marymount vs VMI
Nov 22W
Forfeit
FF Seton Hill vs VMI
Dec 7L
Virginia
INJ 4:03 VMI vs Virginia
Jan 25W
Chattanooga
TF 21-3 Chattanooga vs VMI
Jan 31W
Gardner-Webb
Fall 1:03 Gardner-Webb vs VMI
Feb 2L
Bellarmine
TF 16-0 Bellarmine vs VMI
Feb 9L
Campbell
Dec 8-1 Campbell vs VMI
Feb 14W
Davidson
TF 19-3 Davidson vs VMI
Feb 16L
The Citadel
Dec 8-1 The Citadel vs VMI
Feb 20W
Presbyterian
TF 15-0 Presbyterian vs VMI
Feb 23W
Sacred Heart
TF 17-0 Sacred Heart vs VMI
Mar 7W
Davidson
MD 17-3 SoCon Championships
Cons R1
Mar 7L
Appalachian State
Fall 3:33 SoCon Championships
Cons SF
Mar 7L
Bellarmine
Dec 8-5 SoCon Championships
QF

Best wins

  1. 83Josh McCutchen
    Gardner-Webb, Fall 1:03, Jan 31
    1500
  2. 113Savoy New
    Davidson, TF 19-3, Feb 14
    1404
  3. 123Landon Lewis
    Chattanooga, TF 21-3, Jan 25
    1398
  4. 123RJ Moore
    Franklin & Marshall, MD 9-0, Nov 9
    1367
  5. 133Jake Trovato
    Sacred Heart, Fall 0:57, Nov 9
    1333

Ordered by the opponent’s Elo at the end of 2024–25; the number on the left is their rank.

How the wins came

Fall 2Tech fall 5Major 2Decision 0

Losses by inj (1), tech fall (1), decision (3), fall (1).

Elo through the season

14 rated bouts
16491500