ScorebookIQ
D-I2025–26Elo

Division

Season

Rank wrestlers by

The ranking system changes every list and projection on the site. How they work

PJ Casale

Rutgers, 197 pounds, Division I. 2 seasons on ScorebookIQ, 13–13 in all. On the 2026–27 roster at Rutgers: see the team.

Career recordSeasonsBonusBest NCAA finish
13–13269%–

Career

SeasonTeamRecordNCAA
Rutgers
197 lbs
8–5–
Rutgers
197 lbs
5–8–

Seasons are linked by name, school and weight. Ratings start fresh each season.

2025–26 at Rutgers

Rutgers, 197 pounds, Division I, 8–5, ranked 71st at 197 by Elo rating.

RecordFallsTech fallsMajorsBonusVs top 20EloGlicko-2RPI
8–521375%0–115291518±264.496

Match log

Result
Nov 2W
Gardner-Webb
MD 10-0 Gardner-Webb vs Rutgers
Nov 2W
Angelo Piazza
Centenary
MD 14-3 Centenary vs Rutgers
Dec 7W
Davidson
Fall 4:01 Davidson vs Rutgers
Dec 7L
NC State
Dec 4-3 NC State vs Rutgers
Dec 29L
Ohio State
Fall 1:17 Ken Kraft Midlands Championships
Dec 29W
Cal Poly
MD 18-9 Ken Kraft Midlands Championships
Dec 29L
Stanford
Dec 6-1 Ken Kraft Midlands Championships
Dec 29L
Illinois
TF 17-1 Midlands Championships
7th Place
Dec 29W
SIUE
Dec 10-3 Midlands Championships
Cons R4
Jan 9W
Princeton
TF 18-2 David H. Lehman F&M Open
Jan 9L
Columbia
MD 13-5 Franklin & Marshall Open
SF
Feb 15W
Penn
Fall 0:50 Lock Haven Open II
R4
Feb 18W
Hofstra
INJ 4:43 Hofstra vs Rutgers

Best wins

  1. 51Levi Bussey
    Cal Poly, MD 18-9, Dec 29
    1570
  2. 64Will Conlon
    Hofstra, INJ 4:43, Feb 18
    1540
  3. 81Josh McCutchen
    Gardner-Webb, MD 10-0, Nov 2
    1510
  4. 88Jackson Zimmerman
    Penn, Fall 0:50, Feb 15
    1488
  5. 104Myron Mendez
    SIUE, Dec 10-3, Dec 29
    1439

Ordered by the opponent’s Elo at the end of 2025–26; the number on the left is their rank.

How the wins came

Fall 2Tech fall 1Major 3Decision 1

Losses by decision (2), fall (1), tech fall (1), major (1).

Elo through the season

12 rated bouts
15791487

2024–25 at Rutgers

Rutgers, 197 pounds, Division I, 5–8, ranked 98th at 197 by Elo rating.

RecordFallsTech fallsMajorsBonusVs top 20EloGlicko-2RPI
5–802160%0–214531412±256.452

Match log

Result
Nov 3W
Princeton
TF 18-1 Princeton Open
Dec 14W
Gardner-Webb
MD 10-1 Gardner-Webb vs Rutgers
Dec 20L
Drexel
Dec 8-4 unattached Lehigh Sheridan Tournament
Dec 29W
Harvard
TF 15-0 Midlands Championships
Cons R2
Dec 29W
Penn
MFF Midlands Championships
Cons R3
Dec 29L
Pitt
MD 14-6 Midlands Championships
R2
Dec 30L
Stanford
Dec 6-3 Midlands Championships
Cons R4
Feb 2L
Minnesota
MD 16-6 Minnesota vs Rutgers
Feb 19W
Penn
Dec 4-0 Penn vs Rutgers
Mar 8L
Maryland
Fall 4:58 2025 Big Ten Championships
Cons R1
Mar 8L
Minnesota
Dec 8-6 2025 Big Ten Championships
R1
Mar 9L
Purdue
Dec 11-4 Big Ten Championships
11th place
Mar 9L
Indiana
Dec 6-0 Big Ten Championships
9th place SF

Best wins

  1. 83Josh McCutchen
    Gardner-Webb, MD 10-1, Dec 14
    1500
  2. 109Josh Labarbera
    Penn, MFF, Dec 29
    1417
  3. 129Mason Pellegri
    Harvard, TF 15-0, Dec 29
    1349
  4. 132Nate Taylor
    Penn, Dec 4-0, Feb 19
    1340

Ordered by the opponent’s Elo at the end of 2024–25; the number on the left is their rank.

How the wins came

Fall 0Tech fall 2Major 1Decision 1

Losses by decision (5), major (2), fall (1).

Elo through the season

12 rated bouts
15661453