ScorebookIQ
D-I2026–27Elo

Wrestling

Division

Season

Rank wrestlers by

The ranking system changes every list and projection on the site. How they work

May Cuyler, career

May Cuyler 2025–26

Presbyterian, 160 pounds, women's wrestling. 22–5 in 2025–26; 50–12 over 3 seasons. On the 2026–27 roster at Presbyterian: see the team.

2025–26 at Presbyterian

RecordFallsTech fallsMajorsBonusEloGlicko-2RPI
22–5136086%18331973±184.677

Résumé

What selection committees weigh. Updates with every result.
Win %
.815
22–5 in counted bouts
Vs top 10
3–5
By Elo rank at 160
Vs top 33
11–5
11 quality wins
Bad losses
0
No losses to wrestlers under .500
Schedule
10thof 129
Toughest at 160. Opponents average 1641 Elo
RPI
9thof 140
.677 at 160

Match log

Result
Nov 1W
Newberry
Fall 1:02 Newberry vs Presbyterian
Nov 1W
Huntingdon
TF 10-0 Huntingdon vs Presbyterian
Nov 9L
McKendree
Dec 5-0 Adrian Open
Nov 9W
Vanessa Keefe
Brock
Fall 4:07 Adrian Open
Nov 9W
North Central
Fall 0:41 Adrian Open
Nov 9W
Kylee Tait
Campbellsville
Fall 3:38 Adrian Open
Nov 9W
North Central
Dec 6-6 Adrian Open
Nov 9W
Northern Michigan
Fall 1:13 Adrian Open
Nov 15W
Iowa
TF 10-0 Iowa vs Presbyterian
Nov 21L
King
Dec 3-0 King vs Presbyterian
Dec 19W
Frostburg State
Dec 7-2 Frostburg State vs Presbyterian
Jan 3W
Mount Olive
Fall 1:35 Mount Olive vs Presbyterian
Jan 3W
Schreiner
Fall 0:21 Presbyterian vs Schreiner
Jan 3W
Randolph
TF 10-0 Presbyterian vs Randolph
Jan 3W
Nicole Lewis
Montreat
TF 10-0 Montreat vs Presbyterian
Jan 18W
Forfeit
FF McMurry vs Presbyterian
Jan 18W
McMurry, exhibition, doesn’t count toward the record
TF 10-0 exhibition McMurry vs Presbyterian
Jan 30W
Lehigh
Fall 1:11 Lehigh vs Presbyterian
Feb 20L
King
Dec 3-1 2026 NCAA Women's Wrestling Regional, Region III
Feb 20W
Greensboro
Fall 0:24 2026 NCAA Women's Wrestling Regional, Region III
Feb 20W
Randolph
TF 10-0 2026 NCAA Women's Wrestling Regional, Region III
Feb 20W
Emmanuel (GA)
TF 11-1 2026 NCAA Women's Wrestling Regional, Region III
Mar 6W
Western New England
Fall 2:53 NCAA Women's Wrestling Championships
Champ. Round 1
Mar 6W
Fort Hays State
Fall 1:12 NCAA Women's Wrestling Championships
Cons. Round 2
Mar 6L
King
TF 10-0 NCAA Women's Wrestling Championships
Quarterfinal
Mar 7W
Sacred Heart
Fall 4:09 NCAA Women's Wrestling Championships
5th Place Match
Mar 7W
Simpson
Fall 4:34 NCAA Women's Wrestling Championships
Cons. Round 3
Mar 7L
McKendree
TF 11-0 NCAA Women's Wrestling Championships
Cons. Semi

Best wins

  1. 9Keeley Kehrli
    Simpson, Fall 4:34, Mar 7
    1775
  2. 10Love Daley
    Sacred Heart, Fall 4:09, Mar 7
    1751
  3. 11Elizabeth Rosenstiel
    North Central, Fall 0:41, Nov 9
    1736
  4. 10Cadence Diduch
    Iowa, TF 10-0, Nov 15
    1725
  5. 19Sophia Bassino
    Northern Michigan, Fall 1:13, Nov 9
    1659

Ordered by the opponent’s Elo at the end of 2025–26; the number on the left is their rank.

How the wins came

Fall 13Tech fall 6Major 0Decision 2

Losses by decision (3), tech fall (2).

Elo through the season

26 rated bouts
18591500

Earlier: 2024–25Full careerLater: 2026–27

The week in college wrestling

Every Monday: the biggest upsets, who moved in the rankings, and what stood out across D-I, D-II, D-III and women's. Free.